Is the Vertical as sub-standard as it seems?
-
@jedi2354 Same Problems
-
@wakarimasen and it makes sense to keep your S9PP as sleep tracking and other metrics will be drastically changed and improved soon!
-
@jedi2354 I wouldnāt say it is as much an āissueā as it is a feature that has seen little love over the years. Many have said that it is likely to be addressed soon but itās anyoneās guess when that soon is.
It does not seem that Suunto is the right product for you - maybe an overkill for the āissuesā you describe. As others have pointed, you will get better mileage with screen, sleep metrics and SPO2 with Apple Watch and the like.
If you are within the return period, its never too late!
-
@Tieutieu I also think that sleep stages etc are mostly useless and inaccurate on all watches. But I am surprised by how many on this forum are willing to accept the bad ohr readings. Its 2023 and other manufacturesrs are able to produce sensors that are generally reliable except for maybe interval training. But on the vertical the ohr is just often wildly inaccurate, and I think that has made me regret buying one. I just hate carrying around a smelly chest strap when it should not be necessary.
-
@6294946 what makes you think the current wrist hear rate is accepted?
This is still under improvement (while the size and weight of the vertical of course is a heavy burden) and will be addressed with the next update as well.t6, S6, Elementum Terra, Ambit 3 Sapphire, Spartan Ultra Copper, Traverse Alpha, S7 Graphite LE, S9B Ambassador, S9P Granite Blue Titanium, S9PP Titanium Sand, Vertical All Black, Race Titanium Charcoal,
Race S All Black - TI Canary - Titanium Courtney -
@Egika honest question: is OHR really something that can be improved by SW? I thought the irregularities are caused by the sensor hardware failing under certain conditions. I used S9B for a couple of years and I never saw OHR improving over time. Thatās why I bought the belt.
Compasses: M-311, A-10, SK-7
Diving: Finnlight Navy 90, Vyper
Sports: Metron, S7, S9B and Vertical -
@6294946 Every OHR watch I have had (Polar/Garmin/Coros) for the past several years has the exact same complaint - OHR doesnāt work while exercising seriously. And serious athletes do not rely on OHR - they us an HR strap. Not sure why there continues to be an expectation of what OHR can do vs cant. If you want daily HR or overnight HR, use OHR. If you want feedback on a sporting activity, get an HR belt for now until companies and reviewers start saying āits finally reliableā to ditch the external strap.
My Vertical has been spot on any time I want to get an SPO2 reading, āifā I take the reading correctly (sitting still, and sometimes put some slight pressure on it against the skin), and EXACTLY like Garmin and Coros, sometimes it takes a few times to get a reading.
All these readings need to work in tandem and can give you an indication of overtraining and illness - its why POLAR started way back in the 80ās with heart rate monitors. If you are training too hard, or getting sick, and if you monitor some stats daily, you can notice a trend and back off training a bit. Thats it. Nothing magical. And all of the guides Suunto and other watches provide give you tips on what type of training is recommended.
I think these wrist devices are great if you take in the big picture and look at trends vs one offs? I find these kinds of posts brutal - the watch does what it says, but the screen isnāt as bright as an OLED display, so its sub-standard? Jeezā¦people should read some reviews and online stuff, or go look at one in a store, before you buy maybeā¦
-
@BrunoH said in Is the Vertical as sub-standard as it seems?:
@Egika honest question: is OHR really something that can be improved by SW? I thought the irregularities are caused by the sensor hardware failing under certain conditions.
wrist HR sensors as well as any other sensor are always a combination of hardware and firmware. hardware is sending and receiving light. Firmware is filtering and interpreting the raw signals.
while hardware is fixed, the data processing can be changed with software.I used S9B for a couple of years and I never saw OHR improving over time. Thatās why I bought the belt.
I am not sure if S9B ever saw an improvement of WHR during its wrist heart rate. And it suffers even more from itās weightā¦
Anyway. I just wanted to say that Suunto is working on this for their current models and while I donāt know how much it will change, it is not something that is accepted in itās current state.
-
@Egika Yes! I read this before and am looking forward to new metrics!
-
@Egika said in Is the Vertical as sub-standard as it seems?:
@6294946 what makes you think the current wrist hear rate is accepted?
This is still under improvement (while the size and weight of the vertical of course is a heavy burden) and will be addressed with the next update as well.The Question ist WHEN WHEN WHEN the promised update will COME!!! Since Juli here we read the next update will comeā¦UNTIL TODAY NO UPDATE
If it doesn't challenge you, it doesn't change you. #lifewithasthma #runwithasthma #nevergiveup #pushinglimits #adventurestartshere Suunto D9, 9 Baro, 9 Peak, Vertical Ti, Race , Race s Courtney, SA (Beta) Androidšš¼š§ā·ļøšµ
-
@GiPFELKiND we are on a user forum, not a brand internal social network. Writing in big letters wonāt make things go faster, but hurts the eyesā¦
Come on, our lives donāt rely on that updatesā¦ -
@GiPFELKiND What a fuss about ohr, I have done 1276 training sessions with Suunto watches, one went better than the other, but as soon as it gets a bit cold it always goes wrong.
I always wear an external strap during training.
I run 3 to 4 times a week at an athletics club, most of whose members have a Garmin, they have exactly the same problems with ohr, measuring on the wrist with trained runners just doesnāt work well. Iām glad I have a Suunto when I see all that hassle loading a route with a Garmin for example. -
@GiPFELKiND you seriously need a chill pill
-
@altcmd Yeah, Iām finding it quite tiring now. He just needs to buy a Garmin and be done with it
-
@Egika ok, thanks, very good to hear that suunto is working on updates related to ohr! Not sure if I shouldāve known that. By āacceptingā I mean exactly these comments where people say that ohr is always wrong etc, a good example just here above
My reading of reviews by f.e. Dc rainmaker is that, in general, ohr matches very well on average with a chest trap. (One recent exception was his review of suunto vertical where it has similar problems that I experience on most zone 2 runs.) This has been my experience as well on other watches. I dont need ohr to be super accurate but just consistent. -
@Tieutieu I find it funny that we are not on official brand forum and still can not post links to upcoming new watchā¦ rules are schizophrenic. But this is best we got, so we have to cope with it
-
@Likarnik this is a forum hosted on the suunto.com domain and paid (as far as I know) by Suunto (not sure which department). So, it is an official Suunto forum, and to join you agree to Suuntoās terms and conditions and privacy policy.
What this forum is: a community forum by Suunto for Suunto users.
What this forum is not: (1) official helpdesk for Suunto, (2) the official way to get in touch with the company.Watch: Suunto Vertical Ti
Blog: isazi's home
-
isazi said in Is the Vertical as sub-standard as it seems?:
@Likarnik this is a forum hosted on the suunto.com domain and paid (as far as I know) by Suunto (not sure which department). So, it is an official Suunto forum, and to join you agree to Suuntoās terms and conditions and privacy policy.
What this forum is: a community forum by Suunto for Suunto users.
What this forum is not: (1) official helpdesk for Suunto, (2) the official way to get in touch with the company.And controlled by volunteers.
-
@zhang965 no, it is controlled by Suuntoās community manager (Dimi) and other employees. The moderators are almost all volunteers, though.
-
@isazi out of curiosity: is a volunteer one with similar privileges to a regular user with no privileged, proprietary information and free test products?
