How to set HR intensity zones?

sartoric

I don’t have an S5, but are you sure you didn’t modify the “basic” HR used by all the sports mode ?

michi

@sartoric you are right. Editing the HR zone this was isn‘t specific to the sport, but changes the „basic“ intensity zones. I need to find another way around this.

Mff73

@michi
and what about taking the opposite solution ?
use standard HR zones for all your other sportsmodes, and set the specific running/cycling ones.
For sure it is not one set of zones per activity type, but it may help, no ?

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

Hi there are zones called advanced.

Setup the basic zones for “all sports”
Setup special zones for running based , cycling based, and swimming based activities

When you do running the advanced zones will be used
When you do indoors the basic modes will be used etc

michi

@Mff73 The intensity zones won’t fit for me. I would have to use the basic/standard zones for my rowing, cross country skiing, crossfit etc. E. g. my HR at aerobic threshold is 10 - 15 beats lower in rowing, than in cross country skiing for example.

michi

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos
Thanks. How do I assign a sport to the specific advanced zones? E. g. how do I assign “indoor rowing” to the “cycling based activities”?

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

@michi you cannot. That is missing. So all cycling based sports (ie indoor cycling etc) will use the cycling advanced zones.
For running advanced zones, ie treadmil will use those, then running, trail running (all the yellow stuff).

Yeah a good helpful indicator is the color. So ie cycling = “orange” all activities with orange will use those cycling advanced zones (I am 90% sure not 100%).

But no you cannot apply ie cycling zones to the rowing profile unfortunately.

michi

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos said in How to set HR intensity zones?:

g advanced zones, ie treadmil will use those, then running, trail running (all the yellow stuff).
Yeah a good helpful indicator is the color. So ie cycling = “ora

Thx for your answer. Thats really too bad. What are the chances this issue will be resolved in an upcoming software upgrade?

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

@michi I dont know that unfortunately

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

@michi but in my personal view I have not heard of such a thing.

Can it be done? The mechanics are there I would not say it’s a lot of work though but I have never seen this, or in a form of request.

michi

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos The Suunto 9 is identical regarding customizability of the HR zones I guess?

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

@michi correct.

Imo polar has that if I am correct. Idk about Garmin or COROS tbh.

I can see this as a valid request tbh

fazel

@michi interesting. Are you determining these with lactate testing?

Dimitrios Kanellopoulos

@fazel I think its typical for rowing to be -10-15 bpm.

Also biking to running have this relationship. IE if you do a bike test you can add 10-15bpm for your HR zones of running.

michi

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos Yes Polar has it.
From a sport scientific standpoint it doesn’t make sense to use standardized HR zones for multiple sports. Depending on the amount of working muscle mass and especially body position (standing, sitting, laying) the AT and LT will be at very different heart rates. Therefore, if you want to train in specific zones (and document it correctly in your training diary), there is no way around setting the intensity zones for every activity specifically.

fazel

@Dimitrios-Kanellopoulos great…now I’m reading this article…

TRANSFERABILITY OF RUNNING AND CYCLING TRAINING ZONES IN TRIATHLETES: IMPLICATIONS FOR STEADY-STATE EXERCISE

michi

@fazel With lactate testing you can determine the aerobic threshold and the lactic threshold perfectly. Of course this is costly / time consuming and gives you only the numbers for the sport you tested. If you are serious about it, it’s worth it and you can calculate AT and LT for other activities with thumb rules.

fazel

@michi yeah. I actually have one and have done the InScyd test for cycling. It’s expensive to pay for that test though, so I’m trying to come up with some testing protocols to run on my own. If you are going to do this sort of thing, it’s much cheaper to get a meter and become proficient on your own I think. I tried my own step test last weekend. It’s tough because I’m on rollers so I have to stop between tests which is a pain and might skew the data. Here’s a nice site that runs calculations for you.

Here’s the results for my test. I’ve been reading Olbrecht’s book and trying to employ his philosophy to my training.

michi

@fazel Nice, I have done my step tests on the bike as well. I was given the training advice from the sport scientist to add 10 beats per minute for running when training in zone 2. Me subjective feeling is, that I have to add even more beats when running.

Inscyd looks interesting. I have listened to a couple of podcasts with (founder?) Sebastian Weber. He is very knowledgeable on this topic.

fazel

@michi Yes - I’ve listened to the same podcasts probably. He’s good but his ideas don’t seem to be universally accepted (at least not by the TrainingPeaks/WKO guys). They do align almost completely with Olbrecht though. My sense is Olbrecht is the originator and Webber’s work is rooted in his ideas.

Step tests are a pain. The Inscyd tests are interesting. Mine was four efforts, record levels every minute until they decrease. Efforts were sub-maximal except for the last (3 min). Mine were done at home and Steve Neal ran them for me (another excellent dude). I’m nowhere near elite, but he’s real approachable and took time to go over them with me. I paid for two initially and just have to decide when to use the second.